Bug? Drape of Shame bonus not working?


#1

For my monk healer, BiB is recommending 9.5k crit under Adaptive Raid Healing. However, it is also recommending I remove my ilvl 915 Drape of Shame, with the 5% bonus to crit heals, and replace it with a 915 Cape of Mindless Fury, which I think BiB likes because it has a socket (or maybe its the agi enchant, lol). Doesnt seem right to me, wondering if the Drape bonus is not working?
Shaomai-Aman’Thul


#2

Could you share your export string from the addon ?


#3

Edit: Ugh, my bad, here is the in-game addon export:

$54;US;Aman’Thul;Shaomai;Enigma;13;2;110;13:815,15:658,12:800,8:800,14:716,2:800;2;.s1;16;2123212;1277,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,81,167,1,1,1,98;1,4,4,4,4,4,4,4,4,4,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,4,1,1,11,1;142309b1542b3337b3418,151014b3194b3337b3397,137359b1567b3336b3573;1,1739,32,6,-491,-3,-1,1,1,0,0,0,0/2,457,42,-4,-236,-262,-1,1,0,0,0,0,0/3,461,41,4,-501,-1,-1,1,0,0,0,0,0;.s2;17;1133211;931,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,349,80,170,1,1,1,95;1,1,1,1,1,1,1,4,4,4,4,4,4,4,4,4,1,1,4,1,1,16,1;142186b1552b3337b3418,147106b1517b3337b3562,147114b1502b3336b3562;1,1739,41,4,-845,5,2,1,0,1,0,0,0/2,793,39,-3,-830,-4,-2,1,0,1,0,0,0/3,800,39,-1,-836,-1,-2,1,0,1,0,0,0;.s3;18;2133112;800,1,19,1,1,2,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,261,247,35,173,1,1,1,92;4,4,4,4,4,4,4,1,1,1,4,1,1,1,1,4,1,1,4,1,1,2,1;142194b1527b3528b3573,153465b3174b3337b3573,147115b1507b3336b3562;1,1739,35,9,-961,727,-748,1,0,0,0,0,0/2,938,35,8,-982,749,-728,1,0,0,0,0,0/3,918,35,8,-953,-7,272,1,0,0,0,0,0;.q1;128938s16b732x142309y8705z-13655;1291s12b-131b78b10b2655x14226e5427;8s2b-2743b78b10b1059x-21337e464;3922s14b-1145b969b236b1720b45x21337;36s10b-1976b1740b81e-445;2s5b-3376b1560b1735b81;2871s7b41b111;11s6b-111b111;2034s13b-2963b965b1956b45;3029s1b-2006b1770b81;4879s11b-1916b306b1528b237x0e-16;9s8b-3532b1466b301b1528b226x0;11s9b-2055b1829b226;111s15b-3520b1455b2031b34e6;4s3b-3519b1454b2031b34e493;.q2;128937s16b733x142186y4920z8;3507s2b1078b1759x-16866e5891;1751s10b-1973b1740b81e-445;2s5b-3376b1560b1735b81;254s7b-1836b1755b199;86s12b-1969b1851b110e-17;7605s1b-1961b1770b81;3s6b-1871b1790b81;25s15b-1886b1886b110e7;2088s14b-69b111;2748s13b-2073b2031b34;15s11b-2060b306b1528b237x21337e-6;9s8b-3532b1466b301b1528b226x0;11s9b-2055b1829b226;4536s3b-2962b1087b1721b200b1e499;.q3;128940s16b734x142194y11271z-6350;3504s2b1077b1759x-16867e5891;1504s17;247s10b-1973b1740b81e-445;2s5b-3376b1560b1735b81;250s1b-1836b226b1529b80x-26;4s7b-1835b1755b199;86s12b-1969b1851b110e-17;7608s6b-1981b1790b81;2113s14b41b111;2748s13b-2073b2031b34;15s11b-2060b306b1528b237x21363e1;9s8b-3532b1466b301b1528b226x0;11s9b-2055b1829b226;111s15b-3520b1455b2031b34e6;4425s3b-2962b1087b1721b200b1e493;.r;_;.inv;783;1535;1;140;1773;2;1;69;1481;1163;57;70;1094;1;1;4881;8835;9404;2276;1;252;3882;3;721;131;4545;1026;501;0;1362;1;6984;1;5;263;3271;8129;259;6249;481;486;43;6938;7042;3541u452;3544;0;993;1;3764;126;2;503;3629u53;1u0;1u-12;6878;473;961;51;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;797;149;263;3688;545;362;14;484;471;182;670;239;960;3;0;772;735;0;0;0;1295;274;78;0;0;4;0;22;1301;180;0;2;1;1;1;1;2;1;1;1;1;1;1;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;2;0;0;1;1;0;1;0;0;1;0;1;1;3;259u36b567;54;1;0;0;1;0;0;197b64b18e5327;2b-8b9e-3;3132;65;4;1;1;2;3;1;1;3;652;2;1;1;3;43;157b-49b73b15;1b-88b78b10;82;92b-93b4b89b1025b1694;0b-2812b4b89b991b1728;1b-2808b69b20b992b1727;4b-2808b79b10b992b1727;48b-2676x142309y8705z-13655;2b2x4835y11271z-6350;160;0;176;470;0;318;165b-133b78b10b2655x4470e103;8b-2744b79b10b1093;0b-1181b78b10b1059x-21337e464;667;842;768;1;1050;2;1;1;1;0;2;1;1;3;2;9;1;1;1;1;1;14;8b-191b1780b81;18b-1861b251b1529b81x0e-1;47;75;404b-2815b969b236b1720b45x21337;220b-2969b973b1759b237;62b-2016b1780b81;6b-1836b226b1529b80x-21363;2b-3376b1511b256b1529b199x-3;10b-3495b1511b1785b199;29b-1999b1799b237e-453;41b-1991b1755b199;4b-1969b1770b199e-10;7b-1984b1785b199e2;1802;191;182b-1979b251b1529b81;34b-2815b944b277b1513;270b-1526b1759e6;9b-111b70b41;17b-111b111;23b-111b111;5b-111b111;6b-111b111;17b-111b111;224b-2013b1780b81e11;53b-3376b1505b1789b82;24b-1836b1755b199;3b-1979b1780b81;19b-3377b1491b1996b45;61b-2001b1765b197;57b-3494b1527b1769b237;105;469;256b-2071b2016b10e-11;512b-69b111;234b-2963b965b1956b45;0b-2968b967b1956b45;216b-2066b299b1530;18;0;0;72;180;132b47b3;1b-2b1;1b-3b3;1b-2b2;1b-2b3;1b-2b1e6;1b-1b2;1b-5b4;73;49;86;80b-1883b1834b138;144;22;61;0;0;3;0;0;0;36;0;0;0;201;300b-1992b1962b84;3b-2006b1815b181;6b-2046b2042b14;3b-2041b321b1529b177x1;50b-2012b306b1710b10;10b-2026b1834b109;30b-1953b1844b180e-14;2b-3474b1470b296b1528b183x2e2;4b-2022b1948b83;5b-3486b1455b1839b180e-2;4b-2029b2029b12;9b-2031b1840b178;527;90b-3474b1436b1859b130;69;47;465;42b-3424b1515b1780b236;3b-3531b1500b1795b199;4b-2059b2051b45;6b-2056b1820b80;2b-1935b1854b116e12;33b-1910b1795b199;2;126;1;70;63e-9;1136;735b-77b111;52;85b-1998b1764b237;10b-1986b1750b81;2270;227b-1921b2031b34;18b-2065b2031b34;1b-2065b2031b34;1b-2070b1844b225;10b-2064b311b1720b34;6b-2065b2031b34e-1;7b-2065b2031b34;3b-2045b1820b225;10b-2055b1829b226;111b-2060b1834b226;1b-3520b1455b2031b34e7;1b-3519b1454b2031b34;1b-2065b2031b34;1b-2065b2031b34;1b-3519b1454b2031b34e493;37b-2065b311b1720b34x0e-494;122;32b-3519b1474b1819b226;0b-2050b1824b226;104;60;56;140;31b-2080b326b1720b44;26b-2085b321b1528b236;3369;433;0;0;0;0;1;0;1;9b-2971b1078b1729b200b1e494;8;3b-3009b1078b1730b200b1x21363;65;131b-150b111;27b-111b111;548b-2098b336b1720b86x0;79;3;1;1;1;171;171;147;1;6;81;2;100$


#4

Actually, we need the string of data that you copy from the addon to our website, not the other way around. With that we can load up your character exactly as you see it and check it out in more detail.


#5

Just replying to point out I edited the post above to provide the requested data, not sure if anyone got a notification when I did so.


#6

So i looked into your code.


This is your stats priority, compare to mine.

When i’m doing BiB the drape of Shame, is use.

My guess if, your stas goal asking for more haste and the Drape of Sham isn’t usefull when you need thats mutch haste.


#7

No, it cant be haste that BiB prefers. Click on the cloak in BiB, and you get the ranked list of available cloaks. Number two on the list is a 905 socketed Dreadlord’s Tattered Wingcover (my Drape is all the way down at no. 4). The stats on the Drape and the Wingcover are almost identical, but BiB is willing to give up 126 Int, 185 Vers and the Drape bonus to crit heals, in order to equip the Wingcover and gain only 149 crit and a socket! Surely such a minor reshuffling of stats is not going to be greater than the bonus from the Drape?

What value does Mr Robot put on the Drape bonus? By my calculation, 200% crit heals * 5% bonus * 27% crit chance = 2.7% increased healing. This is an order of magnitude bigger than the numbers on the ranked list of cloaks. Again, are you sure the Drape bonus is properly implemented?


#8

I found the “bug”, it’s isn’t a bug. You had the talent Refreshing Jade. This talent, if better if you have more haste. So, BiB got more haste. Using the Mindless Fury.
If you use Chi-ji, the cape change to Drape of Shame.

So if you keep the Refreshing Jade.

I thinks it’s just because the Drape of Shame isn’t a big upgrade and in fall into the margin error.

Here is the buff, from the drape of Shame. So it’s implemented. I had one 905 on my monks for a long time, and amr keep using it since then.

With the drap of Shame 979 552 HPS

Without : 975 112 HPS

It’s less than 0.4% increased using the sims.

Your calculation is a way to compare it. But as you know, doesn’t use flat weight as you used. It compare all the stuff. So, here with your current gear, the Mindless Fury, is possibly the one you should use. If you dont like it, you can “force” the Drape of Shame.


#9

Also keep in mind that the bonus from Drape of Shame is 5% “extra” crit multiplier, so it’s actually only a 2.5% crit bonus now if you do the calculations how you did it.


#10

Wow, Im surprised to see the benefit of the Drape is so small. Everyone says the cape is still OP even after the nerf. Thanks very much for your help!