😨 Odd BiB Recommendations


#1

Not sure why AMR would suggest a BiB combination that is inferior to another: :confused:

Simply put, that would make the “best” in BiB a false advertisement - not what I subscribed for. :disappointed:


#2

We would need you to provide your addon export string (that you copy from our addon to the site) so that we can try to reproduce your case and see if something is up, or something just didn’t get set up correctly.


#3

$55;US;Shattered Hand;Sethadon;Purebred Donkeys;2;1;110;10:800,15:432,12:734,13:800,14:726,4:800;3;.s1;22;3211113;883,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,447,34,186,1,1,1,80;1,1,1,1,1,4,4,4,4,4,4,4,4,4,1,1,1,1,4,1,1,19,1;151005b3164b3395b3528,152056b1457b3528b3613,147097b1467b3528b3564;1,1739,41,-3,-882,-2,-1,1,1,0,1,0,0/2,847,32,6,-212,-670,-5,1,0,1,0,0,0/3,849,41,-10,-205,-673,3,1,1,0,0,0,0;.s2;23;3221312;834,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,497,34,189,1,1,78;1,1,1,1,4,1,1,3,4,3,3,1,4,4,4,4,1,1,4,1,1,1;141260b1507b3336b3432,151012b3174b3336b3396,137402b1517b1727b3528;1,1739,32,11,-941,-3,8,1,0,0,0,0,0/2,893,41,-5,-929,-5,-3,1,0,0,0,0,0/3,901,42,-6,-933,5,2,1,0,0,0,0,0;.s3;24;1212213;764,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,568,34,192,1,1,1,74;1,1,1,4,1,1,1,4,4,4,4,4,4,4,4,1,1,1,4,1,1,24,1;142191b1547b3337b3417,150279b3169b3337b3579,152054b1472b3528b3610;1,1739,41,-10,-994,-9,806,1,1,0,1,0,0/2,166,42,2,-1007,797,-800,1,0,1,0,0,1/3,966,42,2,-1007,-4,-1,1,1,0,1,0,0;.q1;128868s16b738x151005y1051z-4959;5306s7b834b1956b45;358s12b-2016b1858b113e5428;2902s9b-1951b231b1529b236x4486;1656s8b-2001b1956b45;5154s1b-114b171;15s13b-171b70b101;211s10b-2053b1760b78;2527s3b-1903b296b1529b225x-21363;260s11b-1790b36b1351b369b45x21360e-1;4685s6b-2116b2071b85;5s5b-2136b1859b274;8s14b-2138b1865b276;11s2b-2156b2071b85e12;188s15b-2111b1835b273e-3;.q2;128825s16b739x141260y9752z-13610;4039s6b1072b1819;1675s12b-2053b1760b78e5427;6356s11b-1928b321b5b1703x14183e3;3364s13b-57b70b101;210s3b-2053b1760b79;2307s2b-1844b1956b45e461;229s14b-2071b1835b224;1541s10b-2014b134b127b1720b53;4s7b-2034b164b1626b244;3389s8b-3538b1429b2056b82;4s1b-2123b1850b276;11s9b-3570b1419b1874b277;200s15b-2111b1835b273e-455;4s5b-2153b2071b85;.q3;128827s16b740x142191y8088z1775;5131s17;.r;_;.inv;6948;26872;4606;256;5368e5357;2824;5849;10483;2154;5723;16316;1795;21366;996;4859;3842;688;1645;1534;313;3;1;1;2556b600b74b15b1031b1688;6;33;644;672;472b-2669x141260y9752z-13610;43b-1x13603y1051z-4959;1363b-138b79b10b2683x-16877e71;17;2189b-1561b1819;7b-1819b1819x0e11;11b-171b70b101;6b-1819b1644;53;350b-1644b1819;706;1;1;2;64b-2073b1779b78e-9;333b-1603b1759;2b-111b171;201b-2058b1956b45;44b-3532b1516b1779b81;1b-1840b1760b73;173b-1823b1750b79;21b-1859b1858b113;2b-1966b1774b78;13b-1862b1861b115;59b-1951b1760b80e-3;0b-1855b1855b111;11b-1971b170b1610e10;34b-1780b1858b113e-9;7b-1951b1760b78e-1;1803;372b-1923b235b86;263b-1772b1551b1745b81e9;329b-1866b1785b80;13b-1865b1785b73;53b-1868b185b1609;61b-1774b1966b45;1b-1996b231b1529b236x21363;69b-2021b256b1529b80e5;139;469;199b-1945b2042b14;3b-2051b1859b178;3b-2042b341b1701;6b-2032b326b1528b178x-21363;48b-2027b321b5b1703x21365e-5;505;211b-1949b1769b78;2b-1842b1956b45;2b-2001b1956b45;702;9;7;3;3;59;319;379;11;5;0;0;205b-2086b1849b108;6b-1957b2029b12;2b-2046b1854b178;95b-2027b321b5b1703x0e-6;16b-2029b321b1708b12x-21366;694;542b-1996b276b1610b110x0;59b-1986b1795b77e6;1455;583b45b171;15b-171b70b101;57;3;150b-2053b1760b79;1b-1839b1760b78;10b-1848b1769b237;2186b-114b111x21366y0z0;91;19b-1998b1956b45e455;208b-2086b1850b227;4b-2087b2051b36;9b-2052b296b1529b225x-21365;1b-2080b2046b33;1b-2079b2046b33;2b-2069b1844b225;4b-2059b1835b224;9b-2069b1844b225e0;3b-2079b2046b33;3b-2069b1844b225;143b-2079b1855b227e-455;1b-3522b1445b1849b225;1b-2074b321b1528b225x0;3b-2089b1864b228e495;27b-2072b2036b33e-503;62b-1789b36b1351b369b45x21360e-1;194;256;25b-2091b2046b44;34b-2085b1849b236e1;1b-2090b2046b44e2;292b-3532b1497b169b1822b51;2b-2042b174b1817b51;485b-2032b134b127b1720b53;4b-2034b164b1626b244;4b-2049b180b1816b53;2b-2049b172b1824b53;8b-2034b1981b53e-3;44b-2044b271b1528b245;1102b-2976b972b231b1528b237x-21332;248b-2036b1799b246;1609;0;1;78b-1771b1819x-28e1;7;284b-2163b1869b277;2b-3570b1429b2056b82;3b-2153b2071b85;1b-2126b1850b276;4b-2136b1859b274;0b-2153b2071b85;1b-2156b2071b85;5b-2151b1874b277;1b-3570b1419b1874b277;1b-2141b1865b276;7b-2131b1855b276;4b-2156b2071b85e11;97b-2156b2071b85;91b-2111b1835b273e-3;4b-2153b2071b85;468b-1802b1819x0e-9;154b-2128b255b51b1720b45x21363e12;0b-2071b278b1748b45;148;2;1;3;2;178$


#4

This is strange, the sim and even the gearing strategy estimates in the gear browser seem to agree that Insignia’s the better piece. Optimizing around the Soul rings is complicated with the talent swaps, so my guess would be some edge case there where the optimization engine is wonky. I’m sure yellow will take a look at it when he gets a chance, but for now you can lock in the legendaries you want and the rest of the optimization should still be reliable.


#5

Yeah, that’s what I’ve done - locked in legendaries for 3 different talent combinations. Thank you for confirming what i suspected. I suspect a “fix” could be a little while given the complexities of the situation?


#6

Yeah I’ll take a closer look – I’m working on an update with the allied races first though, hope to have that done today, then I can get on to this and a few other issues on my list.


#7

Yeah for some reason the optimizer is overestimating the value of combinations with the soul ring when you have the surrender to madness talent… will have to mess around with it a bit to figure out why that is.


#8

cool :sunglasses:

thanks for the update :beers: