Curious Best In Bag swap suggestion for -0.02% DPS

Snapshot ID: 0348ba5d9a3e43deadaff4a9ad7d00b2

As title reports, Best in Bags suggesting I swap cloaks and calculates a negative 0.02% DPS change.

Granted, this is practically a rounding error, and my character is in no position to need to care about that kind of difference, but I was surprised and curious to know if this is working as intended (on some basis about overall simulation or something)? Full character export string below if helpful.

Character Export:

$176;US;Alexstrasza;Zonen;Peace Keepers;2;1;90;13:1,15:682,12:1,8:91,4:72;2;.s1;32;;;.s2;33;1111102111211111111111111110010000100011001011000110001110101210110101010110000111011010112112101010000110000101011100011100001121_54;1279599=1_1279603=1_1287555=1;.s3;34;;;.q1;157987s3b1607b3168b10b1474;65s6b-4652b3178b18b1710b3;23s2b-4906b3322b1b1383;11s16b-4749b3218b18e5949;74s12b-3201b3183b17b1b1712b1x168641e-10;2s14b-4904b3173b18b1712;56s13b-4908b3178b18;1591s17v120b-3119b3112b6;5874s11b-3195b3178b18b1710b3e4;985s15b-6474b1570b3173b18;1099s5b-3316b3288b11b1474b37b3;3s1b-4828b3303b11b628b882b4;5678s10b-4833b3318b1627b101;5s9b-5046b3318b1627b103;64s8b-5048b3318b1627b101;300s7b-5046b3318b1627b101;.q2;249664s17n6015b40b11175b1575d1!D81D2F483;314s7b-9655b3517b6134b553b236d1!D8E13E30A;1s1b-6923b6015b123b548b237d1!D8E13D53E;1s10b-6923b6145b540b237d1!D8F184542;2s5b-10436b3514b6135b549b239d1!D8E13CE01;1800s13n0b-6923b6145d1!D8E027C96;1s14b-6145b6144d1!D8E03B93E;5235s6n-1775b-6144b6015b115b795d1c1!D8CD42CAC;2892s15b-6925b6141b784d1c1!D8F1821EB;6s2b-6925b6144b872d1!D8F04B4BF;22s3n996b-7016b6138b787d1c1!D8F178AF0;3826s8n-1915b-6925b6134b791d1c1!D8CD4E4D0;75s9n0b-6925b6015b119b791d1c1!D8CDDA7B3;50s11n0b-6925b6134b882d1!D81D2C0B2;1s12n0b-7016b6134b882d1!D8CDDA72B;13s16n0b-7016b7001d1!D8E4564C7;.q3;157985s1b1607b3168b10b1473;67s6b-4651b3178b18b1710b3;23s2b-4906b3322b1b1383;11s16b-4749b3218b18e5949;74s11b-3201b3183b17b1b1712b1x168641e-10;1s12b-4909b3178b18b1710b3e-1;1s14b-4904b3173b18b1712;56s13b-4908b3178b18;1591s17v120b-3119b3112b6;3468s9b-3215b3197b341b735;3391s15b-5818b1570b3173b18;1104s3b-3331b3303b11b629b881b4;2563s10b-6259b1446b3299b1503b11;190s5b-4723b3198b11b627;2922s8b-3946b3318b1627b101;370s7b-5046b3318b1627b101;.tal;33~77306974~IV Starter 80~1111102111211111111111111110010000111111011001000111101101101210110101010110000111011010112112001000100110100001111000011111101121_54;33~84657033~Method M+ Totemic~1111102111211111111111111110010000100011001001000110001100101210110101010110000111011010112112101010000110000101011000011100001121_54;33~72391329~Delves Totemic~1111112111211111111110110110010000000001001001000110001000110210110101010110000111000010012112201000000110100101110000011100001000_54;.inv;2318!534B4FA5E;855!D4C3E64CA;2289d1!2BBBDF7CB;1486d1!2AC02C7C8;129!4BC70155F;264n2888!006047C0F;829!51BCBA534;1!51BCBAF1F;2284d1!2C101764D;483!40733A765;1!53A1CBC6F;1!3CA3E3301;505d1!2C4F9A641;774!2C53EA3CE;561d1!2C540320E;31!363F5480F;35d1!2C12F52CC;1497!3E8B69221;1!D7916C526;1066!51BCBF96E;317n200!009F5A980;475!420A43463;1!D8FF49AB1;1!3D0A69BC1;808!370DDF3D5;179d1!2C0DA672A;11!D8E14AC18;4011!54E78135F;41d1!8CD7E4AF7;270d1!D4BB87B24;1d1!D4BB87B25;362!5F3C42640;558!D86523C68;1!D8652035B;1!5FF6C73D9;1!5FF1B8CD0;1!D86520238;1!D8000B504;895!2AC02C7C9;242d1!D4BB87B23;659!3D02F7A84;98d1!2AFD69AAD;1700d1!53D2A082B;1d1!53D2A0826;3380!3AD9F1A99;1666d1!32E086930;9d1!32E07A8C9;2468!556C3C4FD;252d1!30134B1C9;232!D7DEFC90E;1!581B8B8BC;1!D85CB52B2;1!D8FF49BBD;1!581B89E29;1!D85CB6739;804!5E31E619A;418d1!34B923D7B;278!D8E14A78B;3000!5E40FD71A;125!D7FFBF3E1;4618d1!3F9BB90F3;1297d1!2C81FE9CA;441d1!579C8E874;49!369592CEB;1636d1!2EEA1DCBA;77d1!2EEA04CE6;2274d1!2D9586843;6d1!2D8E2C17B;406d1!56D4AF81F;901d1!2D7F8B259;1639d1!0097D294C;0d1!0097D2947;529!D8FF4A2FC;163!678F859F0;1!D8FF49B4D;1!5FF6C95E6;1!D83CC8AA8;1!D83CC94B6;254!3A4FD8C61;3!37B92E2AA;3!314AB68F3;115d1!D4BB87B20;11807d1!00972F184;0d1!321CA4BF7;6713d1!009655055;0d1!678FB8EC9;17d1!37C1D11EC;1!6B9885BC1;1!6B72A337D;1!6B9872749;1!6B72916BB;77!6B9889EF7;405!4DFA4424F;43!8BAF30AC6;2084!D8502F661;1!D83CCB1B8;1!D8FF4A27C;1!D86D12582;1811!439841F4B;3040!4E29E431A;7468d1!4D4204A0C;830d1!5524F8BDC;1797d1!3D5125857;9421d1!4E26ABE42;5669d1!00972F966;4617d1!530CD58A7;215!674ED2EC1;1!674ED2EBB;7!5E4860E54;0!56FAD4DCF;0!54B2AE099;567!D8FF49ED0;917!685F00263;1d1!5F713A2C7;0d1!8B5D985DB;634!D81D22280;312!528073643;763b525b5d1!57C3C3E4E;941!531D2606C;1!531D28BD7;1!532A5ADDE;1!5808FDC66;324!67253A482;1422d1!55B6EDF9E;453d1!552467FDD;39!527481D61;2!5FF6C1EEB;4d1!5E4671357;864b2879d1e5331!55C4B60D3;544b-2864d1!554FD1F19;75d1!55C56A910;500d1!55C603896;552d1!554C1E908;182!68B375B18;40d1!55750090B;26d1e-34!5523FC481;48!6717DB07F;15d1!5FAFD59BF;11d1!D67E4DA3B;109d1!671C44E87;247d1!8B0BC2942;182d1!535CD3C30;390d1!8B0BC239C;879d1!007CA6A12;773d1!5573D597F;1419b37d1!D4BB87B22;12b0d1!D4BB87B21;214d1!5FB97D1E5;6d1!5E4859401;1517!8B03B73C7;2!8BAF49282;1!8D6255661;1!8AB811D98;4!8AB80D6F9;3d1!8ABEDC087;313!69C55E350;1!8B03E824B;1!8B98BE596;0!8B4CD93C8;1!D87289B62;0!D84701ECF;1!6A19E9CBB;1!D85CB6083;198!D7DF45029;3733d1!5E321CF7A;134d1!5FBFBC167;3d1!5FBFBC157;73d1!690C9A055;1d1!690C99EA3;1d1!690C99B8D;1d1!690C99A4A;4d1!690C9A13D;1d1!690C9A3C5;1d1!690C9A268;227b163b776d1x141293y-3922z4693p1471p338p3q-341q324q14!68B4A7DD0;92b-775d1!6B67FE912;24b-2b743d1x-779p-343p343p3!6B5D8376A;3237d1!6B8E07346;7526b1896b3d1!8CF865D0A;3b-3b2d1!8AB81751D;3b-1b1d1!8AB819FE7;1b-2b2d1!8AB833CA4;1295d1!670DCE7FA;652d1!8AB852A10;10889!8C4A5BBD2;1!8BB243EA6;5!8F6FBE919;1!8F6FBF34D;28!D4BBBB55B;92d1!8EC604745;207!D6CD242EF;0!8C1CB8635;1!D79169373;1!D83CCBA38;173!8DAAF4790;1!8B0B6DAD8;1113!8BB243EA5;1!8AFF8DF14;557!8AFF8DF12;175!8F1D5ED8A;2033!D865200CA;1145b-1845b3392b1b1383d1!8B19514CD;305!D8A876721;1368d1!8CD7F0FC0;311!8B5DA72ED;1094!D7E455C56;4452d1!8E44157B8;3044!8E43ABC53;1!8CEE6A94C;3179!006B5363A;1!006B53648;3!006B53643;256!006B53669;3!006B5365B;2!006B53660;2!006B53655;1!006B53657;133!D8227A2D7;1!D8227A2D3;16912l1!00726973C;1046d1!00946E713;123l1!00691523E;3!D4C23CB45;1!007269CF7;4!D79A790CA;1!007269D0C;3!0084613DC;2!D4BC6D8CC;2!D4BC74895;2!D79A67D0A;64l3!00627960D;1l1!00726979E;1l2!007269762;60d1!D4C3A1E65;554n-921b871b966b972d1!00946E8E9;383l1!D4C38CDC2;77l1!007269A11;108n678!006705150;2n-556!006A3191B;475d1!D4C38CDBB;40l1!00640339E;1l2!00640339F;540!0067EF85F;22!00691539F;392!D4BC64A55;3!007269B0B;155l1!006A31701;2l2!006A316F9;3l1!006A316E6;1l2!006A316EE;2l1!006A3170B;1l2!0067EF673;5l1!006A316F2;1l2!0067EF665;29!0067EF6D2;1!0067EF6C4;1!0067EF692;1!0069C6B3B;1!0067EF684;2!006A31705;1!0069C6B42;663!D4BC8D025;201!D6F4B7098;1!D4C3A025B;352n666!0067EF7CA;7n0!007269C0D;481n-803d1!0061CD5A2;2777!D4C34BE34;6!D4BC93C67;610n-1d1!D4C30FF1C;723d1!D4C349284;1144!006279814;226d1!006915378;951!D4C34B1E3;2!D4C3047B6;198n13b-321j76l5d1!D4C3A1E53;390!0062A67BD;8823d1!D7FE54D57;116l1!006AA04F0;3l1!006A8A6A2;3l1!006AA04E9;1627l1!0061A1398;101l1!006A6FA2C;3l1!006A8A69D;3l1!006A6FA14;4l1!006A6FA2E;836l1!0064783EC;100!0074DD184;2!006A843F4;1!0074DD195;4094!006AA0725;629!006A6FA27;1!006A6FA03;1!006A91DB0;1!006A6FA35;1607l1!D79168B3E;1l2!D81D2218A;1l3!D7EF8F28D;1l1!D7916BE4A;1l2!D81D2235F;1l3!D81D223C9;1l1!D7FE74403;2l2!D7FE924CC;180!00620EE7D;1620!006A8A6B6;2!006AA04C1;1!0074DD1BB;1!006A8A6BC;5!006A91E04;654l1!00632EB81;138l1!0061A1464;182!006190A35;2!006190A48;2!006190A56;63j36k32l1!006AA04D6;247n712!006A733BF;9n2!005EC5ECD;41n1!005EF4694;924d1!0069153F4;89n-145b824b1199b3j76l4d1!D4C4BE426;1557!009655078;99d1!005F48CA9;142!0061A1563;208d1!D4CBFC7EB;11d1!D4CC0BAB6;1d1!D4CBFC7DE;1541d5!007772468;665d1!0061A14D0;1d1!007A6077F;295n270d5!005DDF3A2;1n0d5!005DDF3B2;1n0d5!005DDF3AC;7n0d5!005DDF39F;1d5!005DDF3AF;4n0d5!005DDF3B7;3109d1!D4F5763D0;1118d1!D7FEAFD8B;0d1!D8CD42CA4;413n-172d1!D67E4DBD9;2211n176b-937b2369b139d1x96754!D4F59A387;1262l13!009F6E92A;0l13!009EEAED3;6l14!D8FF56850;0l14!009F4A49F;3l13!009F5A9A1;1l14!009EF6131;3l13!009F6E935;1l14!009EF613C;1l13!009F4A4A7;1l14!009F4A4AA;1l13!009F1F9F9;1l14!009EF6133;1!009EF6142;169!009F7029B;1!009EF6122;1!009F7029C;1!009F87149;11l13!009EF66BE;2l14!009FA5473;50l13!009D94F90;1l14!009FA5476;1l14!009FA547A;1l13!009ECD8F3;341l13!009F87128;0l13!D8FF5BEDB;2l14!009F7028C;1l13!009F8712B;0l13!D8FF52EE4;1l14!009F70286;1l13!009FA5462;0l13!D8FF52ACA;1l14!009F70289;1!009F70285;131d1!009B863F6;868!009F20623;1!009F2062B;1!009B544A2;1!009B544B8;1!009A55DBC;1!009F2062A;1!009F20626;1!009B544B4;1!009B544B2;1!009A55DC2;1!009B544B3;1!009B544AE;1!009B544AC;2!0097D085E;1!009B544BA;1!009B544A8;1!009B544AA;1!009F20629;1!009B544A6;127l13!D8FF5CACC;0l13!009FA59BE;1l14!009FA5468;1l13!009F4A4AD;1l14!009FA5463;5l14!009FA546D;1l13!009ECCB2E;1l14!009FA5466;1!009FA546B;1!009FA5472;2!009FA546E;3!009FA5471;1!009FA5469;1!009FA546F;612d1!00670516B;56l13!009BC28AF;2l14!009FA5479;1l13!009D92730;1l14!009FA5478;498l13!009F6E92E;2l13!009F6E92B;514!0064725F6;1067l13!009EF612B;958d1!D7FE1070A;312l13!009CEDB9D;1l13!009CEDB9A;52l13!009ED1C63;2l13!009ED1C5E;2l13!009ED1C5B;1l13!009ED1C61;1l13!00996FD19;1l13!00996FD1B;26!008843485;0!009ABD66E;0!009D66EB1;0!009F30163;0!D8FF5B9FC;0!0091D0150;0!0098A9215;0!009F87134;0!00955C008;1!009F8713C;0!0088941BA;0!00991BFCC;0!009EEAECB;0!D8FF5E405;0!00933380C;72l14!00968DB2C;10l14!00968DB0B;2l14!0097AC564;1l14!00996FD1E;1l14!00996FD17;61l13!009ED1C70;1l13!009ED1C6B;1l14!00968DB26;513d1!00946E735;276l13!009ED362A;1!009ED362C;2l13!009B94BA1;1l14!009B94BA4;17l13!009FA59B1;1l14!009FA59B2;2l13!009FA59B5;1l14!009FA5D61;2l13!009FA5D5E;1l14!009FA5D5B;1009n607b-150b1b248l6!009F2D604;3n0b-249b1b247l5!009F2D5D9;2n0b-248b1b248l6!009F2D5F1;7n0b-249b1b248l6!009F2D5E8;2n0b-249b1b248l6!009F2D60E;4l13!009CF83EE;2l13!009F2D589;2l13!009F2D580;0l13!D8F05541C;37l13!009F2D5AE;671d1!D7FD9E818;241d1!007EC2798;244!0092AF2BF;1!00928EF9A;1!009DC403E;1!009519AD4;1!009426D2C;1!009E3BC56;1!009851FE7;3!009C89351;1!009E4C1D3;1!009EA884E;1!0098E964C;1!009CF0DD1;1!00975EFFB;1!0098A91FD;3!009F08E1F;1!008DAEDC4;1!0099A5788;1!009E72837;1!009CF76C1;1!0099CF5D7;2b1169d1!D8CD45EAA;2!0098E965E;1!009E3BC51;1!009D23B95;2!0099A7CA8;15l14!009B4B5A3;364d1!006705389;207!D8FF53099;0!009F6E926;1!D8FF561F4;0!009F2D599;1!D8FF5239B;0!009F6E923;322d1!D4F54D58A;948d1!D8A872444;5d1!D8A870E16;1d1!D7468297D;1d1!D8A8744F8;62d1!D8FF53A2A;224d1!006204FED;1607b-7017b6141b784d1c1!D8FF6B306;7n2400b-6925b6141b875d1!D8FF6B29F;8n0b-7016b4563b1570b792d5!009E4C174;1n0b-6925b4563b1452b118b792d5!009ECD912;13n0b-6925b4563b1452b119b791d1c1!D8E027B5A;13n0b-6925b4563b1570d5!00959A6E9;316b-6133b6138b550b234d1!D8E13E1C8;482n-1108b-6922b6015b120b546b244d5!009F49D04;824!009F30161;2!009FA547B;380!D6F4A53A9;103d1!0061A1104;5d1!0082D9667;16n1108b-6925b4563b1570d5!009F2B928;1n0b-6133b4563b1570d5!0099A5746;95n-4b-6133b4563b1563d5!008DFEBE0;38!009F70295;1322d1!D8E0130EC;97d1!D8F182824;2483d1!D8F1805D2;1d1!D8FF5D973;0d1!0091D019E;819n-2690d1!009401EF0;318d1!009AE2240;1175d1!D7FE1070E;394b-6126b6141b784d1c1!D8F16DFD1;384n0b-6925b6117b809!009F3015D;137!00940E45B;49!009EA9F98;3!007D0300C;6!009C89319;1!0081FCCD4;1!006A64884;1!006A64883;1!006A64881;11!006A64888;4!007870D4E;5!007DA2370;1!0086CBB05;7!0081FCCD1;6!009D5F165;4!008843DF9;208d1!00913929F;579n1915b-6926b6015b119b791d1c1!D8F16DF58;690d1!D88FC6535;2101n779b-6925b4563b1570d5!00955B3E5;1872n-1735b-6133b4659b1458b899d5!009F7029E;98n-959b-7016b4659b1458d5!009F30154;842n0d1!009D26D97;0n0d1!009A21EDF;11n0d1!009B54509;0n0d1!0098AF6F9;246!009F5A999;1!009CE4813;2!009F5A998;31n0d1!D62A426B9;1217d1!D8CDCB5D7;1599d1!D8F178AF2;.gv;.hlv;0|263|276;1|269|276;2|263|276;3|253|276;4|250|276;5|250|276;6|250|276;7|250|276;8|272|276;9|250|276;10|269|285;11|259|276;12|220|285;13|152|285;14|285|285;15|263|285;16|139|276;.ach;61809;42767;42768;42769$

Thanks for the report, I’ll take a look. This is related to the recent consumable optimization/recommendation that we put in – the way we do it is first we optimize your gear, then we choose the best combination of consumables that compliment that gear.

Then to show you an estimated gain from your current gear, we score your current gear with the same set of consumables to do a fair comparison. Well in this case… using the chosen consumables with your current gear is very (very!) slightly better than using them with the optimized gear.

As you noted it really doesn’t matter which of these setups you use – we’ll work on an update that prevents cases like this from happening though as it is a bit of a nuisance for users when the optimizer does things like this.

1 Like

We just posted a site update that should resolve this issue the next time you optimize your character.