Arcane Mage BIB suggesting Heroic Sapling over Mythic Gebbo?

Serious discussion Simulations
1

Snapshot: 9412daa927a34d64af1334e8e4696097

This seems like an issue with how Gebbo is modeled or something? This is a very unexpected result and suspect.

Addon Export:

$180;US;Mal’Ganis;Merlinmonroe;Hidden Lodge;14;2;90;9:91,15:421,12:1,13:93,4:71;1;.s1;17;11100001010111211000012101121010111111110101011000000000000101000011110000101011011101102121211101011111211110000111000101211111_39;1279599=1_1279603=1_1279610=1_1279614=1_1287555=1;.s2;18;1110000101011121100000211112111110000000000000111111100101111111001111211100110111111011010111111011110100001111000101000111211_39;1279599=1_1279603=1_1279610=1_1279614=1_1287555=1;.s3;19;1110000101011121100000211112101111111111001111111111111011111101110000000000000110000110111111010112011210010100001111101010100001_41;1279599=1_1279603=1_1279610=1_1279614=1_1287555=1;.q1;159243s8n1279b40b12659b144b597b222d1c1e7993!EB1626925;20s9n0b-7010b6047b144b597b222b34d1c1!EB071FA1B;196s11n0b-7044b6047b144b597b228d1x240892e-26!EADD0DD0B;34304s15n0b-7016b6047b144b597b222d1c1!EAE373DBE;52007s16n2336b-4870b168b3254b283b1254b20b65b168j40k36l8d1e72!EAE414255;4454s13n-2336b-7352b6047b147b594d1!EB16BF76B;918s2n0b-6788b6047b144b597b228d1x91!EAE2F1045;52s12n0b-7016b6047b144b597b228d1x-93e-72!EAE2B5C3A;28s6n0b-7016b6047b143b598b222b34d1c1!EAEC1B701;18942s14b-7044b6202b480d1!EB4E82088;1398s3n-239b-6682b6202b480b360b2b1d1e64!EB218998B;1s7b-12133b5088b6191b597b253b5d1o159234e-94!EAE6B9E66;1s1b-12124b5078b6194b594b252b4b2d1o91998e80!EB84F9A54;1s10b-13656b1522b11279b597b251b6d1o-91985!EAE6BA497;2s5b-7045b6193b595b250b8d1o79785e-30!EAEB2BFBC;.q2;159243s8n1279b40b12659b144b597b222d1c1e7993!EB1626925;20s9n0b-7010b6047b144b597b222b34d1c1!EB071FA1B;196s11n0b-7044b6047b144b597b228d1x240892e-26!EADD0DD0B;34291s7n0b-7016b6047b144b597b222d1c1!EB257DF42;13s15n0b-7010b6047b144b597b222d1c1!EAE373DBE;52007s16n2336b-4870b168b3254b283b1254b20b65b168j40k36l8d1e72!EAE414255;4454s13n-2336b-7352b6047b147b594d1!EB16BF76B;35s14n0b-6788b6047b147b594d1!EADCDC2C3;883s2n0b-6788b6047b144b597b228d1x91!EAE2F1045;52s12n0b-7016b6047b144b597b228d1x-93e-72!EAE2B5C3A;28s6n0b-7016b6047b143b598b222b34d1c1!EAEC1B701;20340s3n-239b-7044b6202b480b360b2b1d1e64!EB218998B;2s1b-12123b5078b6194b594b252b4b2d1o251232e-14!EB84F9A54;1s10b-13656b1522b11279b597b251b6d1o-91985!EAE6BA497;2s5b-7045b6193b595b250b8d1o79785e-30!EAEB2BFBC;.q3;159259s8n1279b6652b6047b144b597b222d1c1!EB842C625;3285s11n0b-7010b6047b144b597b228d1!EAEB12AC9;31219s15n0b-7016b6047b144b597b222d1c1!EAE373DBE;52007s16n2336b-4870b168b3254b283b1254b20b65b168j40k36l8d1e8039!EAE414255;4454s13n-2336b-7352b6047b147b594d1!EB16BF76B;918s2n0b-6788b6047b144b597b228d1x240983!EAE2F1045;12s9n0b-13626b12657b144b597b222b34d1c1!EAFBA4A57;40s12n0b-7044b6047b144b597b228d1x-93e-72!EAE2B5C3A;28s6n0b-7016b6047b143b598b222b34d1c1!EAEC1B701;18942s14b-7044b6202b480d1!EB4E82088;1398s3n-239b-6682b6202b480b360b2b1d1e64!EB218998B;1s7b-12133b5088b6191b597b253b5d1o159234e-94!EAE6B9E66;1s1b-12124b5078b6194b594b252b4b2d1o91998e80!EB84F9A54;3s5b-7046b6193b595b250b8d1o-12200e-30!EAEB2BFBC;2206s10n239b-7046b6047b144b597b222d1c1!EB1039FB8;.tal;17~52605977~Arcane M+~11100001010111211000012100121010111110110101011000000000000001000011110000101011011101102121211101011111211110000111000101211111_39;17~52605969~Arcane Raid~01100001010111211000022100121110111110110101011000000000000000000011110000101011011101102121211101011011211110000111001101211111_39;18~64582852~Fire Raid~0110000101011121100002211012111010000000000000111101100101111111001111211101010111011011010111111011110100001110010101000111211_39;18~64582862~Fire M+~1110000101011121100000211012111110000000000000111101100101111111001111211100110111111011010111111011110100001110000101000111211_39;19~59070785~Frost M+~1110000101011121100000211012101111111111001111111111111011011101110000000000000010000110111111010112011210010100001111101010100001_41;19~59070781~Frost Raid~0110000101011121101002211012111011111111001111101101100000000000000111111010111000010110111111010110010210001011010001100010111211_40;.inv;6948d1!BDA4BC6DE;31734!DBA7A8659;11131n1279b6652b4563b1486b86d5!00E0DEFEE;78044b-12058b793d1x140810y1498z13538p1472p1864p237q-2101q2056q45r-2101r1864r277!BDA4BC6C2;963b-792b791d1x-8758y-11z4958p-2141p2056p34q-2090q2056q34r-2093r1867r277!BDA4BC6C4;42b-790b791d1x4y3807z4p-2141p1864p274q-2138q1864q277r-2141r2056r82!BDA4BC6C3;22448n0b5130b4563b1484b88d5!00E4A06AC;6765b-11250b3395b1b1383d1!BDA4BC6BE;292n0b336b4563b1484b128d5!00FF63F55;1n0b-6175b6047b147b594d1!EAF376EE1;866n0b-6788b6047b144b597b222d1c1!EAEB68E3D;13n0b-7010b6047b144b597b222d1c1!EAD7E2990;12n0b-7010b6047b144b597b222d1c1!EB842C625;3285n0b-7010b4563b1484b136b833d5!010B01DF5;0n0b-7016b6047b144b597b228d1!EAEB12AC9;6078d1!BDA4BC6C0;601b-12196b4801d1!BDA4BC6BF;24527n0b379b6047b144b597b222d1c1!EB257DF42;16n0b-7010b6047b147b594d1!EB1CE451F;18988d1!00AF7B87E;22745b-3547b2365b143d1x82195e7403!DDE9074CB;1998d1!00BC253D2;1535n0b-5749b6047b146b595b222d1c1!EB24B2636;15n0b-7010b6047b147b594b222b34d1c1e614!EAFFEA990;2262!EAF2F3855;15!EADD15197;917d1!EB2382D9D;34!EAFC02558;472d1!EB2381FFB;858l13!EB84F56C6;1l14!EB84F6C77;128!EAD55DBCE;1611d1!E85012716;2374d1!E7B2FF7D3;6d1!E8501A917;1556n2329b-7044b4563b1562b555d5!00BED6CDA;39n0b-6680b4563b1562b555b245d5!00D6DAF88;1n-2b-6925b4563b1572b546b244d5!00E0DB4C1;938n-2327b-6925b6047b147b594d1!EADCDC2C3;190n3628b-6788b6135b546d5!00DBA6EF8;4n0b-6681b6135b546d5!00BDE2745;4n0b-6681b6135b546b244d5!00D42F697;1n0b-6925b6015b120b546b244d5!00C930783;672n-3628b-6925b4563b1484b136b827d5!010307E6B;18n0b-7010b6047b144b597b228d1x2847e-50!EAD73F854;0n0b-7016b6047b144b597b228d1!EB755AF40;6n0b-13626b12657b144b597b222b34d1c1!EAFBA4A57;45n0b-7044b6047b147b594b222b34d1c1e50!EAF8F2ACA;9n0b-7044b4563b1484b88b790d5!00E55985E;11n0b-6925b6047b144b597b222d1c1e-24!EAFBECE30;11n1745b-7010b4563b1485b742d5!00B0A2BE0;55!EB7DE8DFB;5678d1!00B2CC5D4;1175d1!00D41209B;387n-1745b-6790b4563b1486b86d5!00E546718;60n0b-12747b11175b1452b32b88b790d5!00E021ED7;776d1!EB2382D77;1269d1!E8501B90F;6421d1!EA8525E4F;1200n2961b-13535b12801b491b334d1!EB842FB8C;1b-7016b6192b490b334d1!EB216F320;1334!E7E73A76F;408d1!EA9FA5420;1687n-2961b-7016b6047b147b594d1!EB2EB1668;202!EAD55F37B;1117d1!EB2382DEA;773n0b-6788b6047b144b597b222d1c1!EB1039FB8;6n0b-7010b6047b147b594d1!EAF06B923;697d1!EB12093B1;745n2042b-6788b6141b541d5!00FEED009;2285d1!EAE6498E3;1943d1!EB2382D27;127d1!EB12093B5;542b323d1!EB06226F8;.gv;.hlv;0|321|321;1|311|311;2|334|334;3|318|318;4|308|308;5|311|311;6|311|311;7|311|311;8|311|311;9|311|311;10|321|321;11|311|311;12|331|331;13|302|302;14|0|298;15|0|298;16|321|321;.ach;62410;62411;62412$

2

I can take a look – I don’t see anything wrong with our current simulation of that trinket. It is picking the 6 buffs at random, doing all the stacking and decaying as appropriate, etc.

It is a popular trinket so I’m OK turning up the adjustment on it to make it get picked more aggressively.

Could also be that other trinket is ranked a little high… anything where a thing gets summoned is a recipe for blizzard to screw it up.

3

I posted a couple trinket ranking tweaks for Arcane that you can try out.