Dual Wield, locking enchants doesn't stick

This is the export of my character:
79;EU;Shattered Hand;Mythriel;Element;1;2;120;56;13:155,15:204,12:47,8:155,2:175;2;.s1;4;1311231;0.5.3_1.32.2;.s2;5;1213121;0.7.2_1.32.2;.q1;158075s2b1582b3350b1b1383;287s11b-4734b3201b227e5945;352s17b-3428b3201b227e18;575s15b-3423b3197b226;29s1b-3423b3188b11b634b28a279581a848a-14249a22793a-24995;12s5b-3861b3188b11b633b29a11372a-1516a-9847a4450a-4459;9s3b-3861b3188b11b635b27a14523a-4678a6076a-5555a-10366e-75;6s7b-5406b1545b3197b226;115s12b-3413b3187b226e57;152s13b-4969b1551b3192b226;23s16b-3428b3201b227e17;579s9b-3423b3197b226e9;5203s8b-3329;97s10b-144b3249b14;1175s6b-4757b1489b3252b695;866s14b-4003x167556y1196z-317;.q2;155869s7b1607b3177b225b856;15s15b-4263b3184b224;2191s2b-3428b3350b1b1383;243s11b-4719b3187b18b208x154128e5945;46s1b-3393b3169b662b822a275934a3647a-15597a-22;350s17b-4688b3201b227e18;581s8b-3413b3189b223;14s6b-3397b3171b227;21s5b-3423b3188b11b633b29a11388a-1516a-9847a4450a-4459;9s3b-3861b3188b11b635b27a14523a-4678a6076a-5555a-10366e-75;1s9b-3836b3171b227;120s12b-3413b3187b226e57;6117s13b-3503b3279b12;1978s14b-3322x13428y1196z-317;821s10b26b3282b15b1061;1331s16b-5820b1497b3246b1067b478b21e18;.ess;4_1;5_3;7_2;12_1;15_1;27_2;32_2;.inv;783;1535;1;140;475;1298;2024;692;57;4286;7955;1967;664;1981;8648;251;80;731;297;6;4811;4098;9298;11050;7955;551;1354;8067;354;4734;1256;1713;20006;1442;51;5804;1684;2846;3159;1;19;101b1478b321;444;3160b-1080b827x155848y-4835z4835p1482p2046p82q-2063q1789q61r-1915r2046r82;818;64b-945b78b10;121b32b830x-3801y3799z-3815p-2123p2041p83q-2129q2046q82r-2123r2041r83;3612b1908b171;8b-1819b1819x-21784e5427;1118;4;402b-171b171;2366;672b-1819b1819;8b-1819b1819;16b-171b171x21333e0;28b-1819b1819;5b-171b171e456;19b-171b171;1b-171b171;551;0;493;313;31;0;249;126b-1819b1819x0e-456;95b-1819b1819;228;1015;1254;159;47;208;1;474;125;1389;400b-171b171;30b-1819b1819;13b-171b171;2367;10b-1819b1819x0y4z-1;43;0;45;694;47;209;3426;435;71b-1819b1819x-3e0;14;145b-1819b1819;1b-1819b1819;179b-2158b2056b82;117;1;1;222;194;28;1;1;1;1;1;1;1;1;27;1;2;47b-151b171x0e0;5;7;30;0;353;29;1;1113;1;2;6b354b11;549;162;13;1;1;90;849;22b-2453b3244b33b591;9b-3823b3197b226;15b-3428b3201b227;5b-3438b3214b224;835;2;1;1154b-3433b3198b11b628a279581a-6350a-9244a4450a-4459;2b-3837b3198b11b629a14523a1906a-508a-15937a16e461;32b-3823b3183b11b632a9253a5269a-12320a-2218a16e0;27b-3841b3198b11b627a9253a5269a-14513a-25a16;190b-3826b3199b17;172b-3186b3169b662b823a14522a-5269a6695a-11489e0;2b-4699b3214b16b208x2548;0b-3408b3184b224;8b-3468b3237b7;4b-3204b3201b227;1b-3398b3171b227;0b-3428b3201b227;34b-3423b3197b226;9b-3428b3201b227e57;13b-3428b3201b227;3;747;3;43v120b-3297b3083;116b-3214b3201b227;1b-4969b1531b3214b224;1b-3423b3197b226;5b-3438b3214b224;8b-3423b3188b11b634b28a10065a1900a-16415a10357a-10366;1b-3861b3188b11b633b29a9253a15523a-21817a1657a-4616;3b-3866b3201b19b208x-1;7b-3398b3171b227;0b-4968b1530b3214b224;5b-3423b3188b11b634b28a15603a848a-14249a22793a-24995;2b-3876b3214b224;2b-3423b3197b226;2b-3438b3214b224;1b-3438b3214b224;5b-3453b3218b11b627b29a11372a-1516a-9847a4450a-4459;1b-3900b3244b33b593;7b-3840b3214b224;0b-3398b3171b227;3b-3438b3214b224;3b-3428b3201b227;1b-4968b1545b3197b226;113b-3438b3214b224e0;2b-3433b3206b225e-4;2b-3426b3201b227;125v0b-3315b3101;25b-4755b1551b3192b226;14b-3438b3214b224;2b-3428b3201b227;7b-3428b3201b227e21;16b-3428b3201b227e3;74b-3438b3214b224;234;94;57b-3468b3237b7;104b-4746b1532b3214b224;0b-3423b3197b226e6;184;1;1;118;187;4;1;2;632;1116;1;0;0;0;0;81b-3438b3214b224;6b-3438b3214b224;488;187;75b-3448b3222b18b324b739;11b-4303b3224b16b323;51b-3563b3224b340;0b-3539b3199b339;75b-3593b3254b339b268;2b-3806b3199b339;1b-3538b3199b339;0b-3563b3224b16b323;1b-3503b3164b1059;165;15;81;127;39b-5805b1522b3224;11b-3199b3199b339;912b-3628b3289b356b31;239b-3686b3299b356b110;389b-3571;56b-1641b1477b3269b340;2b-3609b3269b340b291a24900a-1247a-16091a-3103;0b-3945b3313b339b341;1b-3943b3261b343;2b-5085b1471b3271b343;35b-3604b3264b13;1b-3262b3249b14;65b-3273b281b2975b16x1;99b-3212b3199b17;21;4;245;605b-3286b3258b11b340b292a10064a9161a-23675a-25a16e-83;6e55;4b-3901b3258b11b340b291a24900a-1216a-23678a-22a16;13b-3945b3313b339b340;113b-5421b1489b3252b695;105b-3962b3269b693;52;0;42;82;1;41;65;0;0;166b-3952b3259b1538b25;0b-4827b3264b1039b523;64b-4826b3261b1042b25b499;2b-4822b3259b1478b82b3;66b-4837b3274b1035b527;2b-4836b3274b16b1019b527;6b-4836b3274b16b1019b527;85b-4851b3288b1473b94;1b-4845b3278;2b-4742b1464b3274b1074;1b-4348b3278;54b-3278b3278;1b-3278b3278;35;176;155;159;86;1;46;32;45;40;1;24;160;72;86;4;1;152;30;500;1;17;16;109;16;99;20;77;7;145;54b-3298b3299b1503b11;33b-6258b1445b321b2978b12;199b-3301b3289;53;2;351b-3209b3209b629;630b-3893b3264b1057b506e20;37

This is what happens:

  1. AMR suggest my 2 weapons with vers/haste
  2. I would like to change the vers enchant to haste and lock it in place
  3. After pressing re-optimize the “locked” haste enchant is changed to vers again, but still being marked as locked

It is just a bug, but you should be using two different enchants on your weapons. iirc, they share the same proc if they are the same enchant. So, having two different ones up gives you both buffs instead of just one on a shared CD.

I’ll look into it, dual-wield enchants can be quite a pain, lots of edge cases.

And yes – using two of the same enchant will increase your uptime on the buffs from that one enchant, but it is almost (always?) inferior to using two different enchants.

I am aware I want to have 2 different enchants. I want to lock in haste on the 430 MH weapon, because the enchant is already on the weapon. I expect the MH to stay with the haste enchant (because I have it locked in place) and have the OH weapon change to Vers.
The issue is not that I expect the same enchant twice. The issue is that it proposes a different enchant even though I locked the enchant with the lock icon.

There are still issues with this feature. Locking enchants in place when you’re dual wielding does not stick, neither does it stick when swapping between multiple different profiles.

If you could give me a test case, that would help. Click the “help” link next to the big Best in Bags section header, then press Create Support Post. Copy the snapshot ID here, and I can use that to try your specific case.

@yellowfive fc4c3b08d7734bcfb232f964ae449b83

In the WW AoE profile AMR suggests I put Vers on MH and Crit on OH. However, my current enchants are Crit (MH) and Vers (OH) (which is absolutely fine). Therefore, I want to lock Crit and Vers. However, it just doesn’t stick. After Re-Optimize the locked Crit and Vers gets changed to Vers/Crit again.

What I expect is that I lock the enchant on the weapon and it just sticks!

I’ll take a look when I get a chance – it’s respecting the combination of enchants that are locked, but since the weapons are swapped in the solution, it’s putting them on the opposite hand.

I believe the purpose of locking is to lock the enchant to the weapon/item, not to the slot. Right? I mean, locking enchants on rings, or azerite traits work exactly like that.

Yes that is what it is supposed to do – but seems there is a case with dual-wield enchants here where it’s holding on to the proper enchant combo, but letting the weapons swap.

If you were to lock in an enchant you don’t currently have, like mastery, you’ll see that it properly puts on a mastery+other enchant, but that the weapon swaps again. So something must be happening after the fact.