Enchant threshold being ignored

I mentioned I was getting odd behaviour in the post about my mage but it started working again, not sure why but this one is on my druid.
Sorry this is so long, follow through the post in order and, hopefully, you’ll see the odd behaviour too.

I’ve decided I need to play Terror Turkey for a better ranged/melee composition for Mythic Queen’s Court so I’ve set it as top priority, chosen my talents and essence and set the enchant threshold, hit the BiB button and the result says to change two enchants and one gem for a 0.08% increase.
Initially I had the threshold set to 0.25% so I increased it to 0.50% and the same thing, then I increased it to 5% and it still wants me to swap them!
cbea1b518c8748e09e412b8ad6717fbb
That’s the snapshot so you can boggle at it too. :wink:

Addon export

77;US;Proudmoore;Cluey;Eternal Kingdom;6;1;120;70;13:175,15:950,12:175,11:175,4:175;1;.s1;6;1323321;0.22.3_1.5.3_2.12.3;.s2;7;1313132;0.12.3_1.27.4_2.5.3;.s3;8;2323211;0.22.3_1.4.3_2.7.3;.s4;9;2323132;0.22.3_1.27.4_2.20.3;.q1;155860s5b1617b3158b11b662b821a287773a-14902a-5206a7148a-10835;2215s2b-4659b3322b1b1383;1212s15b-4704b3172b226b845;12s3b-4238b3158b11b662b823a8893a8970a-17854a4612a-4621;46s7b-4659b3172b226b840;116s12b-4238b3172b226b840e6108;6104s11b-4313b271b2978b14x168639e0;2784s1b-3298b3273b11b37b1444a8893a30136a-36827a-2218a16;48s16b-4750b3269b14e-145;80s17b-4758b1475b3266b17b1050;199s14x2;211s10b-4348b3281b16b1051e-26;18s13b-4333b3269b14;1236s8b-3288b3274b16b1492b6x-2;164s9b-6258b1470b3274b16b1492b6x0;63s6b-6260b1472b3274b16b1492b6x0;.q2;158075s2b1610b3322b1b1383;1212s15b-4704b3172b226b845;36s3b-4238b3158b11b662b823a274424a5983a-16299a-146a16;12s5b-4654b3158b11b662b821a15549a-5103a-7487a1662a-4621;10s7b-4657b3172b226b840;116s12b-4238b3172b226b840e6108;6104s11b-4313b271b2978b14x168639e0;2741s16b-3283b3266b17b1050e-143;41s1b-4333b3258b11b38b1446a10446a4085a-14525a10829a-10835;540s10b-4768b3281b16b1051e-28;424s13b-4333b3269b14;8s14b-3298b306b2976b15b1061x-2;822s8b-4348b3274b16b1492b6x2;164s9b-6258b1470b3274b16b1492b6x0;63s6b-6260b1472b3274b16b1492b6x0;.q3;158075s2b1610b3322b1b1383;1212s15b-4704b3172b226b845;36s3b-4238b3158b11b662b823a274424a5983a-16299a-146a16;3221s12b-6230b1571b3171b227e6109;5762s16b-3493b3266b17b1050e-144;39s1b-4333b3258b11b38b1446a14527a-5634a-5206a772a-4459;5s5b-4768b3273b11b37b1443a10446a28584a-36071a13076a-16035;26s10b-6224b1475b3269b14;2s7b-3283b3269b14;1s6b-4757b1474b3269b14;297s14x168641;207s9b-3298b3282b15b1061;6s11b-4343b3269b14e144;167s8b-3328b3307b5b18b1068x-2;258s13b-4368b3284b13;.q4;157977s1b1607b3168b11b1478a287251a-8746a-14521a23819a-23825;98s2b-4654b3322b1b1383;287s12b-4714b3184b224e6108;925s15b-3398b3172b226b845;27s5b-4238b3158b11b662b821a14527a1273a-11889a710a-4621;9s3b-4652b3158b11b662b823a10446a5983a-16299a-146a16;22s7b-4659b3172b226b840;116s11b-4238b3172b226b840e0;170s13b-4248b3184b224;8745s10b-3493b3269b14;3s6b-4757b1474b3269b14;18s16b-3283b3269b14e-145;80s17b-3283b3269b14;406s9b-3298b3282b15b1061;173s8b-4388b3307b5b18b1068x168639;256s14b-4368b3284b13;.ess;2_3;3_1;4_3;5_3;6_4;7_3;12_3;13_2;14_3;15_3;17_3;18_1;19_2;20_3;21_3;22_3;23_1;25_3;27_4;28_3;32_1;.inv;3371;2763;1306b1709;4745;1752;574;627;2044;1381;1;460;138;793;15e846;630;530;45;349;8;7;447;220;74;213e1476;2e295;247;1;1;1;447;131;1;8768;143;522;1106;106;116;389;209;2;3178;29;5708;1131;69;3;264;6;944;3698;1845;691;77;395;374;2024;1715;7563;58;6629;548;2400;12109;282;122;852;0;0;1797;2681;2344;1;831;1;2;37;7155x76681e2685;1430;5318;80;42;1;0;4;1;1;0;1;0;0;0;1;1;0;1;0;564;0;0;867;49;948;1704;1;1;1;283;41;493;48;2;0;0;615;62;14;0;1231;0;101;122;125;996;8;949;553e-1;1350;688;1327;1;201;102;1523;2;1;1;1;1;1;12;6;313;1;1;197b-1074b15e122;33;0;1118;1149;727;107;65;1;44;1;1;1;1;140;280;2b75b840x60039y15321z-753p1550p1787p199q-2034q2026q84r-2062r1787r199;7;0;7;33;154;3;311b-841b839x750y3809z-3795p-2049p2041p83q-2099q2016q84r-2110r2026r84;37b-841b847x-25y25z-18284p-2110p2026p84q-2095q1820q275r-2062r1787r199;2b-846b852x18273y-14678z14928p-2029p1829p276q-2047q1772q199r-2019r1820r275;2857;18;8;1;708b1884b171x-708e5;1250;3;2;1;12;4;31e502;3269b-1819b1718b101;16b-1819b1819x0e9;16b-1819b1819;539;1;1;2;43;743;29;1006;7;0;166;353;246;301;94;0;0;0;0;3;0;856;159;255;546;137;0;0;1752b-1819b1819e-497;2616;642;5;149;4796;2;1;1;1;0;0;0;1;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;1;0;0;1;0;1;1;28;1;8;10;16;0;0;0;1;2;52;0;7;3;27;207;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;1;0;0;0;0;1;0;0;0;144;182;284;677;9b353b2;1b-1b13;1b-12b9;2b-9b12;545;63;112;0;1;1;939;43b-2395b3181b227b840;752;1344b-4243b3168b11b1478a287251a-8746a-14521a23819a-23825;64b-4657b3168b11b1478a23273a-7609a-15534a4329a-4459;273b-4652b3171b227e666;48b-3408b3184b224e0;16;461;470b-3398b3171b227;5b-3393b3158b11b662b821a14527a1273a-11889a710a-4621;9b-4652b3158b11b662b823a10446a5983a-16299a-146a16;11b-4684b3188b11b634b28a9366a8497a-14905a13077a-16035;1b-3831b3158b11b662b821a15549a-5103a-7487a1662a-4621;4b-4682b3188b11b635b27a8893a952a-5944a721a-4622;1b-3836b3171b19b208x17056;118b-3398b3171b227e0;4b-3398b3171b227e1;153b-3408b3184b224;15b-3398b3172b226b840;1b-4248b3184b224;422;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;81v120b-3308b3094;191;386;0;24;470;139;667;449;1;83b-4755b1571b3171b227e0;680;27b-3388b3153b11b1059b421a15800a-5346a-6553a-3917a16;307;46;2;761;399;753b-4729b3238b11b38b596a8893a14902a-19894a721a-4622;429;322;290e-167;286;42;82;0;0;1;2;39;47;16;2;0;0;0;0;0;0;306b-3878b3244b1057b506;1b-4822b3259b1057b505;8b-4806b3233b11b1481b79b2a14531a-4085a-7487a1662a-4621;24b-4806b3244b1480b80b2;21b-4806b3244b1482b78b3;90b-6309b1467b3278;28b-3303x-1083y1187z-308p2245p462;7;0;176;0;26b35b3258b11b1482b31b1a10446a28584a-35129a-3917a16;1b-4788b3274b16b1492b6x204;108;20;268;24;30;1;1;86;0;3b-4783b3266b17b1050e23;4;0;17;0;18b-4333b3258b11b38b1446a14527a-5634a-5206a772a-4459;2b-4753b3258b11b38b1446a23795a-9268a-14521a4610a-4616;0b-4753b3258b11b38b1446a10446a4085a-14525a10829a-10835;0b-4768b3273b11b37b1444a10446a4085a-14525a4610a-4616;2b-4765b3273b11b37b1444a15549a-5103a-8244a-2218a16;0b-4765b3273b11b37b1444a8893a14902a-21593a-2218a16;1b-4765b3273b11b37b1443a10446a28584a-36071a13076a-16035;26b-6224b1475b3269b14;1b-3283b3269b14;1b-3283b3269b14;1b-4757b1474b3269b14;108;0;0;0;0;0;137;8;5;2;6;4;1;1;94b-3328b3311b1067;53b-4378b3311b1067;4;30;51b-4348b3282b15b1061;6b-4343b3269b14e144;1b-3298b3281b16b1051e0;1b-4348b3284b13;93b-3327b3303b11b33b1446a9366a26826a-32505a931a-4618;72b-4793b3307b5b18b1068x0;243;0;0;5b-5830b1462b3284b13;7b-3282b3269b14;1b-3298b3284b13;1b-3297b3284b13;1b-3297b3284b13;5b-3297b306b2976b15b1061x-2;13;0;1;1;117;0;19;9;1;0;4;0;5b-5820b6248b12;121;246;318;6;2;10;285;618;103;0;815

I was also poking the custom traits option too as the BiB result is suggesting two Arcanic Pulsar traits and I thought the value past the first one wasn’t that high, so I thought’s I’d see what it would do if I changed it.
I added a rule for Arcanic Pulsar - Exactly one.
It swaps hat and chest to achieve this and says -1.86% DPS which struck me as odd, it also chose Undulating Tides which I’m not a fan of as on Mythic fights you can’t not go under 50% from unavoidable damage.
So I added a second rule Undulating Tides - Zero and hit the button.
It sticks with the same items as before but changes traits but now it’s -2.21% DPS.

I’m quite confused now as I thought it would just swap the Arcanic Pulsar on my hat for Loyal to the End.
Add a third rule Loyal to the End - At least one.
Now the result is showing -0.34 DPS which seems like a good deal as the sims I ran indicated that it’s better than a second Arcanic Pulsar as soon as there’s one other player with it.

I know it’s a beta feature but I thought this was odd enough that you might be interested to see the process I went through, it would have been nice if it got to that result with the first rule. As it turns out if I’d set the first rule as, Loyal to the End - At least one, it would have got to the end result!

Having looked at what it would choose with Balance set as my highest priority I moved it down to third as I really prefer playing Feral and it wasn’t stealing any of the feral gear anyway.
New snapshot d71d16447384422ebbe12319f12159ff.
Clicking on the Alchemist Stone to see where my new M+ Cache trinket sits I see this:


That’s odd, why isn’t it choosing the Font anyway?
I don’t really want to change the gem in my Alchemist Stone anyway as intellect doesn’t help a bear much, so I set the gem quality to rare and it suggests changing the 50 haste gem to 80 intellect which is -0.05% behind, if you click on the gem and look at the list.
So I set the gem quality to uncommon and it chooses a completely different trinket!

I just clicked about why the Font wasn’t being selected and it’s the Max On-Use Items = 1 option, so that solves that part but not the gem choices.

I’m not sure I need to use the activate option on the Shiver Venom Relic if there isn’t another target in range, it reads like the DoT would be better left up than consuming it. I’ll run some sims with the log option and see how it’s programed to use them.