I’m seeing a significant discrepancy between Ask Mr. Robot and Raidbots/SimulationCraft when optimizing my Elemental Shaman, Cielo, for Mythic+.
AMR recommends replacing my Season 2 Ophidian Oracle tier pieces with substantially lower-item-level Season 1 Primal Core pieces. Specifically, AMR recommends using 269 S1 shoulders, chest, and legs (along with my existing S1 gloves) instead of my higher-item-level S2 tier pieces, and reports this as approximately a 5.73% improvement.
Raidbots/SimulationCraft produces the opposite result.
I performed a controlled comparison in Raidbots where the only change was the tier set; all other gear remained unchanged:
S1 Primal Core 4-piece: 115,417 DPS
S2 Ophidian Oracle 4-piece: 125,187 DPS
Difference: +9,770 DPS in favor of S2, or approximately +8.46%.
This is therefore more than a normal difference in secondary-stat optimization. AMR is recommending the S1 4-piece despite both the lower item levels and SimC showing the S2 4-piece approximately 8.5% ahead under otherwise identical gearing.
My concern is that AMR may be overvaluing the S1 Elemental Primal Core set bonus/Stormkeeper interaction, or undervaluing the S2 Ophidian Oracle set bonus.
Raidbots report:
AMR support ticket/reference:
f85b4eb1efc24a03843596b40a921da7
I’m happy to provide additional simulation/export data if needed. I’m mainly trying to determine why the AMR optimizer strongly favors the S1 4-piece while SimulationCraft shows a substantial advantage for S2 when comparing the sets directly (S1 115k DPS vs S2 125k DPS).