Farseer Elemental S1 vs S2 Bug

I’m seeing a significant discrepancy between Ask Mr. Robot and Raidbots/SimulationCraft when optimizing my Elemental Shaman, Cielo, for Mythic+.

AMR recommends replacing my Season 2 Ophidian Oracle tier pieces with substantially lower-item-level Season 1 Primal Core pieces. Specifically, AMR recommends using 269 S1 shoulders, chest, and legs (along with my existing S1 gloves) instead of my higher-item-level S2 tier pieces, and reports this as approximately a 5.73% improvement.

Raidbots/SimulationCraft produces the opposite result.

I performed a controlled comparison in Raidbots where the only change was the tier set; all other gear remained unchanged:

S1 Primal Core 4-piece: 115,417 DPS
S2 Ophidian Oracle 4-piece: 125,187 DPS

Difference: +9,770 DPS in favor of S2, or approximately +8.46%.

This is therefore more than a normal difference in secondary-stat optimization. AMR is recommending the S1 4-piece despite both the lower item levels and SimC showing the S2 4-piece approximately 8.5% ahead under otherwise identical gearing.

My concern is that AMR may be overvaluing the S1 Elemental Primal Core set bonus/Stormkeeper interaction, or undervaluing the S2 Ophidian Oracle set bonus.

Raidbots report:

AMR support ticket/reference:
f85b4eb1efc24a03843596b40a921da7

I’m happy to provide additional simulation/export data if needed. I’m mainly trying to determine why the AMR optimizer strongly favors the S1 4-piece while SimulationCraft shows a substantial advantage for S2 when comparing the sets directly (S1 115k DPS vs S2 125k DPS).

Thanks for the post. I took a look at this today and will post an update soon. I needed to put a little bit of extra logic in the rotation to get more value from the season 2 set bonus, especially for single target situations.

Note that in that snapshot, you are using a stormbringer build and optimizing for M+. Your raidbots test was single target.

With the current gear available to you in your bags, the season 1 set bonus is still going to be better than season 2 for AoE. The s1 4pc is especially strong for AoE, and the s2 4pc is fine, but nothing amazing. The s2 2pc does not buff overloads. The s1 4pc does buff the overloads from chain lightning. It is a much stronger set bonus for AoE situations.

Once you have a full set of higher ilvl gear, the s1 set will be phased out regardless (you can see this if you run BiS).

If you change the gearing strategy to Raiding (single target), you will see that the s2 set bonus is chosen. (It is chosen even before this update, actually.)