How to make it pick the right trinkets

Ask Mr. Robot
1

5743f5321a3e4799998d68aad9497e29

So it wants me to use a green philo stone and a blue instead of my epics. Aren’t the epics just better? The ribbon and essence? What settings do I need to do to make it work?

2

You have “Max On Use Items” set to “None”

Those are both on-use trinkets.