Hi AMR team, thank you very much for implementing the Worst in Bag functionality, it has made my life a bit easier when it comes to figuring out which gear to disenchant/scrap. However I feel it is still pretty conservative. I’ve linked my priest’s export string below as an example, even after selecting all three options for Worst in Bags (Guaranteed Junk, Very Likely Junk and More than 30 ilvls), I still have gear that fills up 3 - 3 1/2 bags.
I was wondering if you could adjust the algorithms for choosing which gear to scrap to be a bit more aggressive, or at least add another option for a more aggressive setting. From reading the blog post, I understand that you have set a fairly conservative scoring method that takes into account that Blizzard might change a spec. Could you have a setting that scores gear based on what the specs with just the current Blizzard implementation would prefer.
Also, I was wondering if you might be looking at this in a different way to how I think of figuring out what pieces to get rid of. Usually the optimal set of gear changes when we get a new piece of gear that is better than what is currently in the slot. So one way I could see Worst in Bags working is to testing upgrades for each slot, one at a time, and see what pieces in the other slots that we have get chosen to make a new optimal set of gear. This way, you only keep the gear that appears in these sets, and trash the rest.
Obviously, if you are not that well geared, there would be a lot of upgrades that would have to test for, so maybe put a limit on that to what would be achievable to get with your current ilvl, i.e. heroic gear for a normal geared character, mythic gear for a heroic geared character, etc, so the computation does grow out of hand.
I’m not sure how difficult that would be to implement, or if it is even possible, but that might prove to be more selective in what gear gets listed in Worst in Bags
My priest’s export string is as follows:
76;US;Dath'Remar;Aelosia;Fidelity;5;1;120;50;10:150,15:141,12:1,13:1,4:150;3;.s1;22;2332321;.s2;23;1312333;.s3;24;1111111;.q1;157873s1b1562b3213b11b625a278629a1778a-16299a10258a-10388;121s5b-3834b3198b11b627a14665a-3102a-7657a-3922a16;5s8b-3826b3199b16b1x154129;4s3b-3211b3183b11b632a11624a-1779a-5934a-3927a16;72s2b-3848b3359b7b878;76s11b-4252b3224b17e5944;4s13b-3246b3228b18;1087s7b-3256b3232b4;218s12b-3241b3237b7e0;3881s10b-3199b3199b339;545s16b-3538b3199b339e20;1553s9b-5083b1475b3269b340e7;65s6b-3619b3279b12;420s15b-3261b3247b15;494s14b-3292b3279b12;.q2;157969s1b1577b3198b11b628a277681a-3999a-5793a710a-4621;3s6b-5371b1519b3224b17;27s8b-3216b3199b16b1x154129;4s3b-3211b3183b11b632a11624a-1779a-5934a-3927a16;72s2b-3848b3359b7b878;76s12b-4252b3224b17e5944;1091s7b-3256b3232b4;218s11b-3241b3237b7e0;1920s13b-4745b1436b3309b12;1961s10b-3211b3199b339;545s16b-3538b3199b339e20;1574s5b-3608b3258b11b340b290a9335a14154a-23359a10258a-10388;48s9b-3909b3277b17e7;158s14b-3244b3228b18;258s15b-3266b3247b15;.q3;157971s3b1592b3183b11b632a277682a-1960a-8785a1663a-4622;28s8b-3831b3199b16b1x154129;35s7b-3251b3233b17b1x-2;2s6b-3231b3214b17;22s5b-3211b3183b11b630a13704a-1960a4204a-11332a-4616;17s2b-3846b3359b7b878;1169s1b-4272b3233b11b33b592a14683a1741a-14222a2257a-4459;4097s10b-3824b3199b339;545s16b-3538b3199b339e5964;1553s9b-5083b1475b3269b340e7;225s14b-3549b3209b17;15s12b-3246b3228b18e-28;4s11b-3226b3209b16b1x0e0;241s15b-3266b3247b15;494s13b-3292b3279b12;.inv;3734;1;2;1775;744;111;581;359;3984;1549;1;2;3;8678;924;199;853;1933;545;65;1;1;0;1899;1791;2834;3;6005;105;0;6356;7685;21529;4852;145;1264;900;4730;1256;976;9;103;1196;132;65;2;24;1954;17;1526;819;7395;1;600;28u505x115809e5310;1u0x4e3;1730;316;6267;1889;956;180;1917;2598;125;11;192;47;5649;4195;0;186;1;1;3;315b739b739b1x17193y52p3p1485p2p250p53p16p0;2b-739;41b-2b740x-29p-321p321;9133;2191;1413;2180;8791;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;1;0;0;0;0;91;207;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;1;0;0;0;0;0;0;1;554;3;1;2;2;1;1;38;1216;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;0;10;1;1;192;939;732;393;910b84b3213b11b625a278661a9679a-24232a4329a-4459;0b-3849b3213b11b625a14651a1778a-16299a10258a-10388;2b-3849b3213b11b626a14667a1762a-12528a-3917a16;30b-3850b3224b625;0b-3849b3224b625;0b-3849b3224b625;1b-3849b3224b17;31b-3256b3228b10b680a16451a-11830a-4621;1b-3903b3224b17;1b-3241b3213b11b626a8797a5854a-10747a718a-4622;30b-3850b3213b11b625a9329a375a-5796a713a-4621;0b-3834b3198b11b628a13703a-3999a-5793a710a-4621;0b-3867b3228b10b680a14665a-10044a-4621;1b-3913b3233b17b1x20680;1b-3241b3213b11b626a8797a9066a-13959a718a-4622;1b-5369b1519b3224b17;22b-3226b3198b11b627a14665a-3102a-7657a-3922a16;0b-3836b3198b11b627a14683a-979a-13695a4450a-4459;5b-5371b1520b3221b20;1b-4763b1522b3224b17;0b-4760b1534b3207b19;1b-3241b3224b625;0b-3849b3213b11b625a11744a-1899a-5944a715a-4616;2b-3849b3213b11b626a11744a2939a-12481a-2218a16;0b-3820b3183b11b632a11624a-1779a-5934a-3927a16;0b-3856b3213b11b626a11624a-1779a-5934a-3927a16;23b-3850b3213b11b624a9329a-532a-4889a713a-4621;6b-3848b3224b17;1b-3226b3198b11b628a23358a-13507a-9721a10258a-10388;0b-3852b3213b11b625a14665a-3102a-11433a10258a-10388;0b-3849b3224b625;2b-3834b3209b629;2b-3853b3224b17;21b-3226b3198b11b627a8797a532a-5424a711a-4616;93b-3851b3224b17e629;0b-3241b3224b17e2;3b-3256b3238b18;1b-3246b3228b18;5b-3246b3224b22e1;0b-3246b3228b18;1b-3251b3233b18;0b-3251b3229b22e-1;0b-3251b3233b18e1;0b-3251b3233b18;1b-3241b3224b17;62b-3231b3211b20;91b-3276b3248b10b33b647a16432a-11811a-4621;23b-3908b3228b18;30b-3276b3251b7;10;0;0;0;864b-3238b3232b4;14b-3241b3237b7;203b-3244b3237b7e-2;1b-3244b3237b7e1;1b-3259b3251b7e-1;498;0;0;0;0;150;154b-3223b3221b20;756b-3251b3233b18;34;309b-4763b1447b3296b15;18b-4757b1436b3309b12;9b-3316b3301b15;10b-3311b3296b15;38;1024;80b-3271b3251b7;3b-3258b3251b7e1;27;0;9;1;3;28b-3223b3213b11b625a24362a-9681a1240a-15937a16;424;0;217b-3849b3224b340;11b-3564b3224b340;11b-3549b3206b342;64b-3563b3213b11b339b274a14683a-11724a-2975a16;404;145b-3837b3224b16b323x420e20;0b-3563b3224b340e-2;4b-3549b3209b16b323x0;0b-3563b3224b16b323;841;33;668b-3633b3292b340;4b-3647b3304b343;22b-3607b3258b11b340b290a9335a14154a-23359a10258a-10388;37b-3924b3283b11b39b587a13704a-4894a-8801a4607a-4616;1b-3920b3283b11b39b585a14667a10157a-20922a-3918a16;1b-3918b3294b15;5b-3294b3279b12;3b-3306b3283b11b39b587a9329a15442a-24641a4491a-4621;1b-3905b3277b17e9;158b-3244b3228b18;13b-3261b3243b18e-28;1b-3241b3224b17e0;0b-4763b1517b3228b18e0;3b-4762b1511b3233b18e2;20;245;316;181;223b-3206b3187b19;3b-3211b3191b20;87b-3286b3269b340;3b-3609b3269b340;46;931