"Find Best in Bag" shows me 4 items that are not in my bags (or bank)

[yellowfive]

First give the steps in this post a try:

How to reset all gear data in the in-game addon

Sometimes old item data can get cached in the in-game addon and cause issues on the website. Usually this happens if you haven’t played a character in a long time, but it can sometimes happen for other reasons. In most cases the following will resolve any related issues: Go in-game, and make sure the AMR addon windows is closed. Go to your bank, leave it open for 1 or 2 seconds – that’s enough time for our addon to scan it. Using the in-game talent UI, activate each of your specs once. Open th…

(It was written for the retail version of the addon, so you can skip step 3, the “activate each spec using the talent UI” part since classic doesn’t have the concept of a spec in-game.)

Let me know if that clears it up, and if not we can try some other things.